MARKET INSIGHT · EARNINGS INTELLIGENCEPolaris Earnings CalendarTrack market technicals, follow the S&P 500 outlook, stay ahead of company earnings, and explore crypto technicals—all in one place.

POLARIS EARNINGS CALENDAR

Google makes AI part of the price of Search for schools that want student access

Google makes AI part of the price of Search for schools that want student access

Google said on Nov. 3 that K-12 schools using its education software will be able to control access to Gemini, Gemini Notebook, Gemini in Classroom and Google Search, but schools that reject Google’s artificial-intelligence features will not be able to provide students with Search through managed accounts.

The announcement came with Google’s launch of Guided Learning, an AI feature designed to lead students through problems instead of immediately supplying answers. The company said Guided Learning would be available globally in Google Classroom and would also be built into Search. In an example provided by Google, a student entering a difficult physics problem or asking for help with a book report would receive prompts intended to encourage critical thinking and work through the underlying concepts.

Google said the four services will be turned off by default for K-12 student accounts until school administrators activate them. The company described that change as giving schools more control after hearing concerns from educators and policymakers. But the company’s vice-president and general manager for education, Chris Phillips, said Search and AI are “deeply integrated, ” meaning students at schools that decline AI would see a notice that Search is unavailable.

A later clarification from Google said schools can activate Search separately from Gemini, Gemini Notebook and Gemini in Classroom, but it did not offer an AI-free version of Search for schools that want to block generative AI altogether.

The policy followed an earlier August decision to enable Gemini for many K-12 students using Google Classroom. That move triggered objections from school leaders and child-safety advocates who wanted administrators, rather than a technology provider, to determine when students could use chatbots. The November change reversed the default setting for those products, but left schools that want Search with an AI component to manage the central conflict.

Google’s position has drawn criticism from education officials, technology advocates and politicians. New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani said the company was using its control of Search to push AI into public schools, while former Federal Trade Commission Chair Lina Khan argued that the policy showed the risks of allowing one company to control an essential service. Fairplay executive director Josh Golin urged schools to disable Google’s AI tools and consider alternatives if they believe the systems are unsafe for children or undermine independent thinking.

The dispute is especially consequential for districts that rely on Google Classroom, Chromebooks and related services. Google says 150 million students and teachers worldwide use Classroom, while school-issued devices and accounts can make changing search providers difficult for students and administrators. The immediate decision for schools is therefore not only whether to permit Gemini or another chatbot, but whether access to a familiar research tool is worth accepting AI features that the school may otherwise prohibit.

Edward Markey has asked Google to explain the policy and whether it can technically provide Search without AI features.

Read the full account of the story

More from the AI desk

More from AI · Back to Polaris Earnings Calendar